Here's a breakdown of how recirculating hoods are treated, and what the regulations mean for installers and homeowners.
1. Recirculating Hoods and Building Regulations
Under Approved Document F (ADF), which governs ventilation in England, a recirculating cooker hood does not count towards the required kitchen extract ventilation.
Difference between Appliances:
- Extractor Hood (Ducted): A traditional extractor hood pulls air, moisture, and grease from the kitchen and expels it to the outside via ducting and an external vent. This system is effective at removing pollutants and moisture from the home, and it fully meets the requirements of ADF. The minimum extract rate for this type of system is 30 litres per second (l/s).
- Recirculating Hood (Filter-based): This type of hood, also known as a filter hood, pulls air from the kitchen, passes it through a grease filter and then a carbon filter, and then re-releases the "cleaned" air back into the room.
Key limitation: While it removes grease and odours, it does not remove moisture. This is a critical point, as the buildup of moisture from cooking can lead to condensation and mould. For this reason, it is not considered an "extract ventilation" system under the regulations.
2. Recirculating Hoods in New Builds vs. Existing Homes
New Builds (and Major Renovations): In a new build, extension, or major refurbishment that adds a kitchen, you are legally required to install a mechanical extract fan that vents to the outside.
- You can still install a recirculating cooker hood, but it must be in addition to a separate extract fan that meets the ADF requirement of 60 l/s (as it's not a cooker hood). This separate fan would typically be a wall or ceiling fan located elsewhere in the kitchen.
Existing Homes (Minor Work): If you are simply replacing a kitchen in an existing home without making changes to the structure, you are not legally required to upgrade the ventilation system, unless the existing ventilation is made "less satisfactory" as a result of the work. However, Building Control would still recommend installing a ducted extract system to prevent moisture buildup.
3. Measurements and Compliance
ADF only specifies measurements for Ducted Fans: The minimum extract rates (30 l/s for cooker hoods, 60 l/s for other fans) apply to ducted systems. Recirculating hoods have no specified minimum performance requirements under ADF because they do not fulfil the function of extract ventilation.
Installation - A Professional Should Do This:
- Electrical Safety: Installation of any fan, whether recirculating or ducted, falls under
Part P of the Building Regulations for electrical safety. A
qualified electrician should always carry out the work to ensure it is safe and compliant.
- Building Control: For new builds or major renovations, the installer must ensure the whole-house ventilation strategy, including the kitchen extract, meets the requirements of ADF. This will be checked by a Building Control inspector.
- Commissioning: For a ducted system, the installer must be able to prove that the fan, once installed with its ducting, meets the required airflow rates. This is done through a commissioning test, and the results must be documented and given to the homeowner and Building Control. A recirculating hood does not require this commissioning.
4. What This Means for Installers
Knowledge is Key: Installers must be fully aware of the distinction between ducted and recirculating hoods and how they relate to Building Regulations. They should not advise a customer that a recirculating hood is a compliant replacement for a ducted one in a new build.
Advising the Customer: When discussing kitchen plans, especially for new builds or extensions, installers must explain to customers that if they choose a recirculating hood for aesthetic reasons, they will still need to install a separate, ducted extract fan to meet legal requirements.
Responsibility for Compliance: The installer is responsible for ensuring that the work they carry out is compliant with all relevant regulations. Failure to do so could result in an enforcement notice from Building Control, requiring the work to be redone.
Documentation: For ducted systems, installers must provide the required commissioning and testing documentation to demonstrate compliance. This provides a clear record for both the homeowner and the Building Control inspector.